1001 SEO Media
All posts
By 1001 SEO Medialocal SEOGEOGoogle AI OverviewsChatGPT

Do ChatGPT and Google AI Overviews recommend different local businesses depending on the user's city or postcode? What we see in client work

An SEO and GEO agency's view on whether ChatGPT and Google AI Overviews change local recommendations by city or postcode, and how we audit it for multi-location clients.

Short version from our side of the desk: yes, and it is easy to miss. A business owner checks ChatGPT from the office, sees their name, and assumes the job is done. Then a customer two towns over asks the same question and can get a different shortlist. Local search has always worked this way in Google's map results. What's new is that the AI layer does it too, with less documentation and fewer reports to tell you.

What the platforms actually tell us

We start every local audit by separating what is documented from what is folklore.

OpenAI is fairly clear in its support documentation. ChatGPT may estimate where you are from your IP address. Exact device location only comes into it if the user turns that permission on. If a partner search provider is involved, ChatGPT search reworks your question into one or more narrower queries, possibly with your general area attached, and keeps the IP address and account details to itself. OpenAI lists no ranking factors and says placement isn't guaranteed.

Google's page "AI features and your website" says the usual SEO best practices apply to AI Overviews and AI Mode, with no extra requirements. To show as a supporting link, a page has to be indexed and eligible for a snippet. Both features may use a query fan-out, may run on different models, and so show varying answers and links. Google also lists keeping your Business Profile and Merchant Center information up to date among its practices.

Google Search Central guide titled AI features and your website

The guide Google keeps for site owners on AI Overviews and AI Mode, captured November 21, 2026.

Neither page puts a number on how much a local shortlist changes from one postcode to the next. Anyone who quotes you one is guessing.

Where classic local SEO still does the heavy lifting

This is the part where being a full-service shop helps. Google's own advice for AI features boils down to doing ordinary SEO properly, and for a local business that still means a complete, accurate Business Profile, consistent opening hours across directories, location pages with real content about each branch, and reviews that describe the services you offer. If the listing data is wrong, we fix that before touching anything AI-specific, because Google names it directly.

ChatGPT is a different animal. Whatever its search partners send back for a place-tagged version of the question shapes what it recommends. So the same location page has to be reachable by OAI-SearchBot, and your host or CDN has to let OpenAI's published search IP ranges through. A firewall rule that blocks crawlers the marketing team assumed were welcome is one of the first things we look for.

How we audit it for a multi-location client

  1. We write the prompt set with the branch managers, not just the head office. People in a market town ask "who does same-day boiler repair round here", not "best HVAC services".
  2. We run that set from each location separately. In Promptwatch, the platform we run client programs on, that means a monitor per city on the Business plan, or a pinned coordinate with a radius between 20 m and 5 km where postcode-level detail matters. ChatGPT takes the exact pin. Google's two AI surfaces work from whichever named place is closest to it, and everything else runs from the city or country set on the monitor.
  3. We read the citations, location by location. When a competitor wins in one town and not another, we compare the sources behind both answers: directory listings, local news pieces, review pages. Promptwatch's citation analytics list them per answer.
  4. We check the crawler logs for the location pages, then the AI-referred visits by location in visitor analytics. A page that gets named but never visited is a different problem from one that is never crawled.

One detail we share with clients who doubt that Google's AI answers follow location: when Promptwatch fixed how pinned Google monitors send location (changelog, November 6), its test had 46 of 48 AI Mode answers coming back for the pinned metro, against 32 beforehand. It is a small vendor test, not an industry study, so we treat it as a sign that location matters rather than a rule for how much.

What to do this month

If you have more than one location, don't judge your AI visibility from one desk. Book a Promptwatch demo with two of your branch addresses ready, or send us a note at hello@1001seomedia.com and we'll set up the comparison with you. Either way, fix the Business Profile basics first. They help in classic results and in AI Overviews at the same time.