Which tool suggests prompts to track from my Google Search Console data? How we do it for clients
How our SEO and GEO team turns a client's Google Search Console queries into AI prompts worth tracking, and the tool that suggests them for us: Promptwatch.
When a new client asks us to "do GEO", the first file we open isn't a ChatGPT transcript. It's their Google Search Console property. Months of queries, impressions, and clicks are the closest thing a business has to a record of what its market wants to know, and they're already sitting in an account the client owns.
The hard part is turning that record into prompts. So here's how we do it, and which tool now does most of the lifting.
Why search queries make a good starting point
Classic SEO and AI search overlap more than the hype suggests. Google's own "AI features and your website" page says the best practices for SEO remain relevant for AI Overviews and AI Mode, with no extra requirements to appear in them. If a topic earns a client impressions in Google, buyers care about it, and there's a fair chance they're asking an AI assistant about it too.
What Search Console can't do is tell us how those AI conversations go. Google's documentation says AI feature appearances are counted inside overall search traffic in the Performance report, under the Web search type. We can't filter them out. That's the blind spot a prompt tracker fills.
The manual version we used to run
Before tooling caught up, our process looked like this:
- Export the Performance report for the last few months.
- Strip out branded and navigational queries, plus anything support-related.
- Group what's left by topic.
- Rewrite the strongest queries in each group as questions a buyer would actually type into ChatGPT. "crm for estate agents" becomes "Which CRM do small estate agencies use to track viewings and offers?"
- Load the rewritten prompts into a tracker and wait for data.
It works. It also eats a day per client, and step four is where junior team members tend to write prompts nobody would ever type.
The tool that suggests them now
We run client programs on Promptwatch, and its Prompt Explorer has taken over steps one to four. It suggests prompts from Search Console, from ranking keywords, from People Also Ask, from manual search, or from any page on the client's site. The Ranking keywords tab is handy for competitor research: enter a page or domain and it looks up the Google keywords that page ranks for, then turns them into prompt ideas.
For multilingual clients, the language picker matters more than it sounds. The language sets what the prompts are written in, and the country still sets the market, so a Belgian client can get French prompts measured against the Belgian market.
Before anything goes into tracking, Prompt Volumes gives us monthly volume, a difficulty score, and citation rates across AI search, Google, and Bing. That's how we argue with clients about which prompts deserve their limited slots.
![]()
Promptwatch's prompt tracking feature page, captured November 8, 2026.
Where the SEO side comes back in
This is the part we like most as a full-service shop. Once prompts are tracked, Promptwatch shows Search Console data again, per page. Each page in the sitemap view has its own Google Search Console and Bing Webmaster tabs with clicks, impressions, CTR, and top queries. So when a pricing page starts getting cited in AI answers, we can look at its classic search performance in the same place instead of switching tools.
The Content Agent uses Search Console too. When it picks internal links for a new article, it favors pages with many impressions and few clicks, which is exactly the list an SEO would hand a writer anyway.
What we still do by hand
We still review every suggested prompt before it's tracked. Tooling is fast, but it doesn't know that a client's biggest query is a product they discontinued last spring. We also keep the branded share of each prompt set small on purpose, because a panel full of brand-name questions makes visibility look better than it is.
Try it on your own property
If you want a quick read before committing to anything, Promptwatch's free AI Visibility Report scans ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity for your site and checks AI crawler access. It's a good way to see the gap between what you rank for in Google and what AI engines say about you. And if you'd like us to build the prompt set with you, get in touch at hello@1001seomedia.com.