Which tool finds listicles that mention my competitors but not me? How our agency does it
How we find best-of listicles that name a client's competitors and skip the client, using SEO tools for discovery and AI citation data to decide what to pitch.
Clients ask us this in almost the same words every time: "There's a 'best tools' article with all our competitors in it and not us. How many more are there, and which ones should we care about?" It's a good question, and for years the answer was a classic SEO one. Search the category, collect the roundups, pitch the editors. That still works for Google. For AI search, we've had to add a filter.
The old method, and why it's only half the job
Our SEO team has always found competitor listicles the same way: search queries like "best [category] software" and "[competitor] alternatives", scan the ranking pages, use a backlink tool to see who links to which rival, and build an outreach list. The list is usually long. Some of those pages rank well and send traffic, so the work isn't wasted.
The problem is prioritization. A long list means months of pitching, and we had no way of knowing which of those listicles actually shaped what ChatGPT or Google's AI Overviews told buyers. Some roundups get cited constantly. Others, including some well-ranked ones, never appear in an AI answer.
The filter we add now
We run client programs on Promptwatch, and it answers the "which ones matter" half. We track the client's commercial prompts, the "best X for Y" and "X vs Y" questions buyers actually ask, and Promptwatch records every page those answers cite. Each citation carries a content type, so we can filter to listicles. A competitor filter then narrows it to listicles that back a rival's mentions.
Offsite Mentions does the comparison we used to do by hand. Promptwatch scans the cited third-party pages for brand names and lists which brands appear, ranked as opportunities. When the client's name is missing from a page that names three competitors and gets cited for their core prompts, that page goes to the top of the outreach list.
Don't only chase the big names
The second thing AI citation data changed for us is which sites we pitch. Classic PR instinct says aim for the biggest publication. Promptwatch's report "ChatGPT Citation Share by Domain Rank, August 2026" suggests otherwise. Across August 2026, domains rated DR 46 to 75 earned 46% of ChatGPT citations. Sites at DR 91 to 100 averaged 4.4%, falling to about 3% from August 14.

Promptwatch data report, "ChatGPT citation share by domain rank in August 2026", captured November 14, 2026.
So we stopped sorting the outreach list by domain authority alone. A mid-sized trade publication or specialist review blog that keeps turning up in the client's citations gets pitched before a famous site that never does. The smaller sites also tend to answer email.
What we do with the list
For each cited, competitor-only listicle, we decide between three moves.
Pitch for inclusion. If the client genuinely fits the list, we contact the editor with something useful: a product update, a fair comparison, data they can use. We don't pay for placements and we don't pitch lists the client doesn't belong on.
Track the page. Promptwatch's Page Tracker watches a URL, including someone else's, and shows how many responses cite it and for which prompts. If an editor updates the page, we see whether the new version keeps getting cited.
Publish the client's own version. Some editors never reply. Then we write a comparison or alternatives page on the client's site, honest about where competitors are stronger, so there's a first-party source for the same prompts. Promptwatch can build a content brief from a cited page, which saves us the research step.
Where classic SEO still helps
The SEO side of our team still runs discovery in web indexes, because new listicles appear constantly and not all of them get cited straight away. The difference is that discovery feeds a watchlist, and AI citation data decides the order we work it in.
If you want to see which listicles AI engines cite in your category, Promptwatch's 7-day free trial is enough to track your main prompts and pull the first list. If you'd rather we run the whole thing, from discovery to outreach to your own comparison pages, email us.